In Women's Heart Attacks, a Doctor's Gender Matters

08 Août, 2018, 05:06 | Auteur: Yves Courtet
  • Male doctors are believed to misdiagnose heart problems for women or underestimate their risks

'Our work corroborates prior research showing that female doctors tend to produce better patient outcomes than male doctors, ' said Seth Carnahan, a co-author of the study from Washington University in St Louis.

The study was based on more than 500,000 patients admitted to hospital emergency departments for acute myocardial infarction - a medical term for heart attack - in Florida between 1991 and 2010.

"We find that gender concordance increases a patient's probability of surviving a [heart attack] and that the effect is driven by increased mortality when male physicians treat female patients", said Dr Brad Greenwood, associate professor of information and decision sciences at the University of Minnesota.

The team analyzed almost two decades of records for every patient admitted to Florida emergency rooms with a heart attack between 1991 and 2010. Finding these differences are important because a large body of research shows that women are less likely to survive heart attacks, in general.

"Most physicians are male, and male physicians appear to have trouble treating female patients", said the report.

And the research showed that the gender gap for patients treated by female physicians was only about 0.2 percent: 11.8 percent of men died, versus about 12 percent of women.

But why? Some experts have suggested it may be because women's symptoms are different than men's, or that they tend to delay treatment more often than men. In addition, the more female patients a male doctor had previously treated for heart attacks, the better the chances of survival a woman had.

Lyme Disease Has Spread To All 50 States, Report Finds
Levine said that as long as Lyme disease and Lyme carditis are caught early, they can be treated effectively with antibiotics. Levine says while tick-borne diseases can cause serious illness, Lyme disease, including Lyme carditis, is treatable.

Le réalisateur du film Minecraft quitte l’équipe
Il a en effet confié, simplement et directement à The Wrap , que "Non, cela n'arriverait pas", qu'il ne dirigera pas le film. Warner Bros a cependant missionné Aaron et Adam Nee, des frères qui ont notamment écrit le scénario de The Last Romantic .

Chelsea consider last-minute bid to hijack Bernard’s Everton move
A host of European clubs had been tracking the Brazil global since his previous contract at Shakhtar Donetsk expired earlier this summer.

When patients were treated by male doctors, 12.6% of men died compared with 13.3% of women.

Heart disease is the number one killer of women and men in the USA, and symptoms of heart attack can show up differently in men and women.

Rather than rely on women to act as test dummies for inexperienced doctors, though, it'd better to just stock our emergency rooms and health care centres with more women doctors. Dr. Robert H. Shmerling, who is the author of the Harvard Health Publishing blog post "Does your doctor's gender matter?" wrote about a few more reasons. Given the cost of male physicians' learning on the job, it may be more effective to increase the presence of female physicians within the emergency department. "Male physicians may be less "deliberate" in addressing complicated patients' problems (as suggested by past research)".

And because heart attacks come about suddenly, patients are rarely able to choose their doctor - or his or her gender - when entering an emergency department. This statistic does not signal well to gender equality in medicine or young women considering the specialty-and it may have even darker implications for patients.

Although it is helpful to keep these findings in mind, no one should wait to be treated in an emergency situation - especially with heart attacks where early treatment matters.

Among patients who survived, women treated by male doctors spent more time in the hospital before being released, further suggesting worse medical care.

Aditi Vyas, M.D. specializes in radiology and occupational and environmental medicine and is a resident in the ABC Medical Unit.


  • Jürgen Klopp sets the record straight on Jordan Henderson's Liverpool future

    Jürgen Klopp sets the record straight on Jordan Henderson's Liverpool future

    Liverpool completed their preparations for the new Premier League campaign with a 3-1 win over Torino at Anfield this evening. "Hendo is so important to us, not only as a player but also as a person and as a leader", Klopp told the Liverpool Echo .
    Body found by Iowa police not that of missing college student

    Body found by Iowa police not that of missing college student

    According to WHO-TV's exclusive by reporter Justin Surrency, Cheney pleaded guilty in two previous stalking cases. She told Fox News that she reported it to the Federal Bureau of Investigation when she was questioned.
    Man of moment Mo'unga no guarantee of All Blacks start

    Man of moment Mo'unga no guarantee of All Blacks start

    He sent France-bound winger Seta Tamanivalu over via a cut-out pass and sliced through to set up fullback David Havili's try. Scott Barrett's late try sealed the Lions fate and underlined just how hard it is nowadays for sides to win in New Zealand.
  • Fils de légende de la Formule 1 a dépassé son père

    Nul doute qu’elle offrira à Mika la meilleure option pour poursuivre sa carrière dans le sport automobile. Et il n'est pas Andrei Arshavin, pour répondre à la question sur les attentes facilement et naturellement.
    BWS: Subtropical Storm 'Not Threat To Bermuda'

    BWS: Subtropical Storm 'Not Threat To Bermuda'

    A high surf warning has been issued for east shores of the Big Island in anticipation of the impacts of Hurricane Hector. Survivors may also register online at or by phone at 800-621-3362 or (TTY) 800-462-7585.
    Alexis Kohler visé par de nouvelles accusations — Conflit d'intérêts

    Alexis Kohler visé par de nouvelles accusations — Conflit d'intérêts

    Une période durant laquelle il aurait été placé en position de conflits d'intérêts comme le révèle Mediapart . Interrogée par l'AFP, la présidence n'a souhaité faire "aucun commentaire" en raison de l'enquête en cours.
  • Facebook a-t-il demandé aux banques américaines les données de leurs clients ?

    Facebook a-t-il demandé aux banques américaines les données de leurs clients ?

    Les pratiques du réseau social en la matière sont passées à la loupe depuis le scandale Cambridge Analytica éclaté mi-mars . Déjà en posture difficile, Facebook risque de s'attirer les foudres de bon nombre de ses utilisateurs.
    A's acquire right-hander Mike Fiers from Tigers

    A's acquire right-hander Mike Fiers from Tigers

    In the face of rumors he might be heading to one of the hottest teams in baseball, he'd have been forgiven for being a tad disappointed.

    Votre voiture doit être dans un état impeccable

    En ce qui concerne la sécurité, le choix des pneus parfaitement adaptés est extrêmement. Mais tout d’abord, vous devez savoir où trouver les pièces compatibles avec votre voiture.
  • Japon : une touriste française portée disparue

    Japon : une touriste française portée disparue

    Nous sommes en lien constant avec les autorités japonaises depuis son signalement. Elle aurait juste emmené un petit sac, selon le propriétaire de l'hôtel.
    Club bowler who denied batsman ton gets nine-game ban

    Club bowler who denied batsman ton gets nine-game ban

    Minehead CC players Angus Marsh took to Twitter and dubbed the incident as "the worst cricket moment of my life". Thanks for all the support today!' As usual, British media figure Piers Morgan led the charge.
    Samuel L. Jackson Will Be Back For SPIDER-MAN: FAR FROM HOME

    Samuel L. Jackson Will Be Back For SPIDER-MAN: FAR FROM HOME

    Directed by Jon Watts, Spider-Man: Far From Home stars Tom Holland as Peter Parker, the friendly neighborhood Spider-Man. This will be the first time Nick Fury and Maria Hill have encountered Spider-Man in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.


L'Usine Auto: Elon Musk envisage de retirer Tesla de la Bourse... énième coup de com' ou hypothèse sérieuse ?
Auquel cas, il s'agirait, selon le cabinet Dealogic, de la plus grosse opération de rachat d'entreprise par LBO . Tesla n'a pas répondu aux sollicitations de commentaires dans l'immédiat.

Lawyer: Ohio State never contacted Courtney Smith
Numerous attendees at the rally had signs blaming ESPN , a media company that has had little role in the original reporting of the saga.

Red Sox analyst Jerry Remy's cancer has returned
NESN announced the longtime analyst's diagnosis and said his "focus is on his medical treatment". He revealed upon his return that he had been battling depression.

Perseid meteor shower to offer a spectacular show this weekend
As many as 100 meteors, or shooting stars, can be seen per hour during the shower's peak between Saturday and Monday. It's time once again for the annual Perseid meteor shower, typically the greatest shower of the year.

Elon Musk Wants to Take Tesla Private at $420 a Share
Tesla has been publicly traded since 2010, and has seen its share price rise from just under $20 then to $360 at time of writing. A deal at $420 per share represents a 22.8pc premium to Tesla's closing price on Monday, valuing the company at about $72bn.

Le rappeur Booba aurait pu s'appeler... Jacky !
C'est une chanson que vous avez écrite. À l'origine, la série s'appelait Jacky l'ourson, et moi, ça ne me plaisait pas beaucoup . De plus, Jean-Jacques Debout prend la parole sur le clash entre le rappeur et Kaaris à l'aéroport d'Orly.

Kovacic refuserait de s'entraîner — Real Madrid
Toutefois, plusieurs clubs veulent s'offrir ses services, c'est le cas de l'Inter, de Manchester United et de Manchester City. En effet, l'international croate souhaite quitter la Maison-Blanche afin de glaner plus de temps de jeu.

Travis Scott shares "STOP TRYING TO BE GOD" video
But bizarrely, she has made no mention of the fact she stars in her boyfriend's new video. But when Jenner and Scott do partake in a public outing, it's always one for the books.

Jen tackles Matt LeBlanc over Friends reunion snub
There is a pressure on women to be mothers, and if they are not, then they're deemed damaged goods. That hasn't stopped Jennifer Aniston from fantasizing about returning to Central Perk, though.

Un drone survole le fort de Brégançon, une enquête est ouverte
Une enquête a été ouverte lundi après le survol du fort de Brégançon (photo), où Emmanuel Macron passe ses vacances, par un drone.