Federal judges can not block gerrymandering

28 Juin, 2019, 19:27 | Auteur: Anatole Charbonneau
  • Federal judges can not block gerrymandering

Earlier this week the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit sent the case back to the Maryland district court in order to evaluate the new claim.

In one ruling, a majority of justices said federal courts can not block voting maps drawn by the state lawmakers to benefit their own political party. The process is known as gerrymandering.

"Seems totally ridiculous that our government, and indeed Country, can not ask a basic question of Citizenship in a very expensive, detailed and important Census, in this case for 2020", he wrote.

In a ruling on Thursday tied to the practice of partisan gerrymandering, the Supreme Court - as it's charged to do - weighed in on the perceived intent of the Founding Fathers, the wording of the United States Constitution and lower court findings on the matter. The court's conservative majority says the issue is a political dispute, not a legal one. Together, they were a reminder that gerrymandering is a bi-partisan scourge on voters, an affliction perpetrated by the powerful wanting to keep power, regardless of political party.

The court rejected challenges to two congressional voting maps. The other was drawn by Democrats in Maryland. Voting there typically is evenly split, but the gerrymandered congressional districts produced 10 Republican and 3 Democratic House members.

Later he acknowledged that he had discussed the issue with immigration hawks including Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, who was on the president's disbanded voter-fraud commission, and former White House chief strategist Stephen Bannon, before pressing the Justice Department on the question.

Progressives launched the litigation campaign for a federal ruling on partisan gerrymandering at a time when it seemed that Hillary Clinton would win the presidency in 2016, ensuring a sympathetic majority on the Supreme Court thereafter.

Justice Elena Kagan disagreed with the ruling. "Kagan said that, "for the first time ever, this court refuses to" fix a constitutional violation because it thinks doing so is not part of its job".

"Around the country, machine politicians must be thinking they've got a free hand to draw maps even worse than the ones last round".

Whether the citizenship question returns to the courts or not, several scholars noted the significance of the Supreme Court's pointed rebuke of the Trump administration. "Instead, they are opening the door for more of it, including by the Utah State Legislature".

The decision effectively reverses the outcome of rulings in Maryland, Michigan, North Carolina and OH, where courts had ordered new maps drawn and ends proceedings in Wisconsin.

NASAs Curiosity rover finds new methane spike on Mars
The rover, about the size of a small SUV, landed in August 2012 and has since been sending images of Mars's surface back to Earth. The new Mars rover measures 10 feet long (3 meters), 9 feet wide (2.7 meters), and 7 feet tall (2.2 meters).

Hamilton fastest in first Austrian GP practice
Hamilton led from start to finish in the race and Mercedes is heading for its sixth straight drivers' and constructors' championship.

Martens fires Netherlands past Japan and into World Cup QF's
We can see that from the viewing figures, what we see in the press and from the messages we receive from back home'. Japan might be getting healthy just in time for the knockout stage, but they aren't playing very good soccer.

"Partisan gerrymandering claims present political questions beyond the reach of the federal courts", Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in the majority opinion.

The Supreme Court has effectively blocked the Trump administration from adding a citizenship question to the 2020 census, arguing that the government's reasoning for the proposal was inadequately explained.

Warren took time from a visit to a Florida migrant detention camp to post a Twitter thread calling the ruling a "welcome relief" but noting that it may still be possible for the Trump administration to add the question.

Justice Clarence Thomas, however, said including the citizenship question was within the Commerce Department's authority.

While the constitution permits the Department of Commerce to "inquire about citizenship on the census questionnaire", Roberts wrote, "if judicial review is to be more than an empty ritual, it must demand something better than the explanation offered for the action taken in this case".

Disputed congressional maps in North Carolina and Maryland can't be declared unconstitutional for political reasons, the Supreme Court ruled on Thursday, a decision that could have a sweeping effect for states like OH and MI where officials remain at odds over whether updated district designs are too partisan.

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross wants to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census.

Roberts also said that the Department of Justice wasn't interested in the citizenship data until contacted by the Commerce Department.

Democrats have complained that asking USA residents if they are citizens will discourage illegal immigrants and other non-Americans from participating, resulting in a less accurate head-count.

Plaintiffs in both cases won in lower courts, prompting the states to appeal to the Supreme Court.

After arguments before the high court, opponents of the question informed the court they had obtained "new evidence" that the decision was politically motivated. Kelly Jean Kelly was the editor.

Conseillé:



Populaire

Fifth North Atlantic right whale found dead on Canadian island
Measures have been put in place to prevent more deaths by reducing the potential for ship strikes and fishing gear entanglement. According to CBC News , it is estimated that there are only 413 North Atlantic right whales left in the entire world.

We now know what Beyonce's Real Hair Looks Like
In the post's comment section, one fan wrote: "Y'all can't tell Bey ain't got no hair. slayyyyyyyy that attractive hair Mrs. I guess, every baby-mumma relationship evolves through the same phase, irrespective of their ages.

U.S. Democrat de Blasio apologises for Che Guevara phrase in Miami
We are supposed to break up big corporations when they're not serving our democracy. The Miami Herald has attempted to reach his campaign but has not yet heard back.

Donald Trump at G20 Summit in Japan
This year's G20 Summit will be held in the Japanese city of Osaka, while next year it will be held in November in Saudi Arabia. This was Modi's first meeting with Trump after the BJP's landslide win in the parliamentary election.

Angelique Kerber swats aside Simona Halep to reach Eastbourne semi-finals
The Wimbledon champion converted five out of seven break points to secure the win and set up a last-four clash with Ons Jabeur . Pliskova, who won in Eastbourne two years ago, dropped just two games outclassing Russia's Ekaterina Alexandrova 6-2, 6-0.

Nottingham Forest sack Martin O'Neill, Sabri Lamouchi appointed new head coach
Roy Keane, O'Neill's assistant, also left the club on Sunday which was seen as a significant blow to the manager's authority. The 67-year-old's return to Nottingham Forest lasted just six months after the club chose to terminate his contract today.

Donald Trump expects 'productive' meeting with China's Xi Jinping
India slapped higher duties on 28 U.S. products after the United States withdrew tariff-free entry for certain Indian goods. President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping deterred traders from making bold directional bets.

Man Utd linked with shock attempt for Arsenal striker Aubameyang
He chipped in with 22 goals last season as he shared the Golden Boot with Liverpool's Sadio Mane and Mohamed Salah. Italian outlet Tuttosport claim the 30-year-old is open to leaving Arsenal for Manchester United.

Marianne Williamson's oddball debate answers have made her into a meme
During her closing statement, she spoke directly to Trump, saying she will meet him "on that field" and defeat him with " love ". So I have a feeling you know what you're doing. "You've harnessed fear for political purposes and only love can cast that out".

Henry Cavill Set To Play Sherlock For Legendary’s Enola Holmes Adaptation
Brown can now be seen on the big screen in Godzilla: King of Monsters as Madison Russell, a role she will reprise in Godzilla vs. Henry Cavill and Millie Bobby Brown are all set to be a part of the Sherlock Holmes world in Enola Homes.