Ontario's top court says federal government's carbon charge is constitutional
01 Juillet, 2019, 08:47 | Auteur: Therese Cote
The Ontario Court of Appeal ruled in a split decision on Friday. The country's highest court has already agreed to hear an appeal of a separate reference case from Saskatchewan on December 5.
The constitutionality of the pricing system will ultimately be determined by the Supreme Court of Canada.
The act now only applies in four provinces - Ontario, Manitoba, New Brunswick and Saskatchewan - which Ottawa says don't meet national standards.
The Ontario Court of Appeal decision is a major victory for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who is heading into a fall election campaign in which climate change will likely be a major issue. McKenna said earlier this month the federal carbon price would come into force in Alberta starting January 1, 2020. During four days of submissions in April, Ontario insisted the act would undermine co-operative federalism.
The highest court in the province of Ontario has ruled that the federal government does have the power to impose a carbon tax as part of its effort to combat climate change.
Speaking on behalf of the court on Friday, Chief Justice George Strathy said, "The need for a collective approach to a matter of national concern, and the risk of non-participation by one or more provinces, permits Canada to adopt minimum national standards to reduce (greenhouse gas) emissions".
Like other provinces, the government plans to have the standards in place in the summer of 2019 and will work closely with the federal government to ensure Ontario industry is not double regulated. They simply said Ontario had one of the best records, emissions 22% below 2005 levels, without a carbon tax and that the Paris targets could be met without a tax.
Ottawa is increasing the carbon tax on new natural-gas plants as part of the final regulations for its carbon-pricing system for big industrial greenhouse-gas emitters.
"They are regulatory in nature and connected to the purposes of the act", Strathy wrote.
The federal government maintains the levy in Ontario - now four cents a litre on gasoline - is a regulatory charge created to change behaviour in favour of lower greenhouse gas emissions. Ontario's Progressive Conservative government calls the charge an illegal tax, arguing the federal government overstepped its authority in imposing the charge.
Saskatchewan province - with the backing of New Brunswick - went to court last month to try to block the federal levy but lost. He said the tax leaves ample scope for provincial legislation. The pricing mechanisms also "incentivize behavioural modifications", he said.
A majority of justices on the Saskatchewan court found that requiring a national price on carbon pollution fell within federal jurisdiction under the national concern branch of the POGG power.
The province said it will appeal today's decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.
In a joint statement, Ontario Premier Doug Ford and Environment, Conservation and Parks Minister Jeff Yurek said the province was "disappointed" with the ruling and would appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
At the time, Moe likened the ruling to losing the first game of a playoff series.
In a statement issued last week, Alberta Premier Jason Kenny, said his government is now preparing its own challenge to the carbon tax.
The couple met in late 2016, after Joe direct messaged Sophie on Instagram , on the suggestion of mutual friends. We'll eagerly await more reports of the big day as they come in. " "We knew it was something unique".
Nigeria have already sealed their place in the last 16 after recording two 1-0 wins against Burundi and Guinea. The runners-up of Group B will take on the runners-up in Group F on July 6, also in Alexandria.
Yang's lack of airtime didn't go unnoticed by his passionate fans, with the hashtag #LetYangSpeak trending on Friday morning. The top four in the gabbing department were former Vice President Joe Biden (13 minutes, 19 seconds), California Sen.
Whelp, we're all probably going to die at the hands of these dum-dums, so let's enjoy the memes while they last! Another wrote: "She's like a little kid who's trying to get on the adult table at the Thanksgiving dinner".
Should they decide to, and someone come up with the right offer, then they've already lined up his replacement. The speculation comes amidst rumours that former Everton forward Lukaku wants to move to Italy and join Inter.
According to a source, team president Steve Mills wants players who fit the bill of being able to tutor their young players. They went into this season with the expectation of signing Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving to go alongside Zion Williamson.
Hutchinson was originally selected by the Boston Bruins in the third round (77th overall) of the 2008 NHL Draft. Marincin, 27, suited up in 24 games for the Maple Leafs last season, registering one goal and four assists.
The crash involved a Beechcraft BE350 King Air, which can carry up to 13 people. 10 killed in a plane crash near Dallas, Texas. Photos and videos showed thick plumes of black smoke billowing from the site of Sunday's accident.
According to Reuters, Trump expressed understanding for Turkey's decision but did not rule out sanctions in response. And then as soon as he buys something else, everyone says 'okay, you can buy.' You can't do business that way.
The final amount of concrete was the largest ever recorded in the United Kingdom , beating a record set by the Shard in London , said EDF.
Transfer: Why I'm joining Juventus - De Ligt
Italian League champions Juventus are reportedly planning to confirm the signing of Ajax captain Matthijs de Ligt on Monday. Then, when they met again in the UEFA Nations League final, it was Ronaldo who emerged victorious.
Toy Story 4 bests Annabelle Comes Home and Yesterday
The film saw a "re-release", of sorts, with new scenes added to the cut now in circulation which brought more fans to the seats. Toy Story 4 repeated at the top of the United States charts, earning $57.9 million according to studio estimates.
Taylor Swift Accuses Scooter Braun of 'Bullying' Her
This is what happens when you sign a deal at fifteen to someone for whom the term "loyalty" is clearly just a contractual concept. Taylor Swift is left utterly in dismay as the person she never wanted around her music will now own her entire music catalogue.